Tanzeel Akhtar is an independent British journalist whose work has been published in the Wall Street Journal, CNBC, FT Alphaville, Investing.com, Forbes, Euromoney and Citywire.
The following article is an exclusive contribution to CoinDesk's Crypto and Taxes 2018 series.
When tax season ends, will the crypto bear market end with it?
With the April 17 U.S. deadline to file approaching, there's much speculation that the crypto winter of 2018 was largely due to investors frantically selling to raise funds, so they could pay taxes on 2017 gains.
"We may look back on this time as the 'Crypto Tax Crisis of 2018,' as thanks to tax liabilities we're witnessing the most concentrated period of net fiat outflows that the cryptoasset ecosystem has experienced in its short life," Chris Burniske, a partner at Placeholder VC, and Jonathan Cheesman wrote in a recent, highly detailed Medium post.
And there has almost certainly been some tax-related selling, judging from posts on Reddit and various cryptocurrency forums from investors who had cashed out cryptocurrency during the December run-up and became concerned about their tax liability.
"I didn't know this back then but it looks like I owe income taxes on those trades, which adds up to about $50,000 if I add up state (California) and federal," a Redditor who goes by the handle of thoway wrote a month ago.
Further, Japan's tax deadline was March 15th. Like, the U.S., Japan is a huge participant in the crypto market, so this would further support the thesis.
But there are several reasons to discount the contribution of such selling to the recent market rout – and thus the probability that prices will suddenly surge again after Tax Day.
Coming up short
First of all, investors who sold during the slump would not likely have raised enough to cover their tax liability. Perry Woodin, Chief Strategy Officer at HashChain Technology, Inc, did the math.
"Imagine an individual who purchased 1.5 bitcoins in January of 2017 for $1,200 a bitcoin," Woodin told CoinDesk. "If that individual sold one bitcoin in December of 2017 they could have realized a gain of ~$18,000. This short term gain is taxed as ordinary income in the U.S. Assuming a tax rate of ~30%, the tax liability would be about $5,400."
As we spoke in early April, bitcoin was trading around $6,700. Hence, Woodin said, in his hypothetical example, "the remaining 0.5 bitcoin (or $3,350) is not enough to pay the $5,400 tax liability."
So, tax-driven selling would have been irrational. Of course, people don't always behave rationally.
Trevor Gerszt, CEO of CoinIRA, a company that specializes in digital currency individual retirement accounts (IRAs), gave another reason to doubt a strong connection between the crypto slump and tax selling. He pointed to the recent activity on the bitcoin blockchain, or lack thereof.
"If tax selling were really a driver of bitcoin prices, we would expect to see a spike in selling, yet confirmed transactions have been relatively low and have remained that way for the past two months," Gerszt said on Tuesday.
To be sure, major exchanges started batching transactions in the first quarter, so the number of liquidations reflected on the public ledger might be understated.
Eric Ervin, CEO of Reality Shares, which has launched an exchange traded fund (ETF) investing in blockchain technology, said taxes were certainly a factor in the performance of crypto, but not the primary one, as evidenced by the timing of the dips.
"The market selloff began in December, first bottoming in February, and now we are retesting the lows we saw in February," Ervin said Tuesday.
There's no point in trying to sell your crypto holdings in a panic just because Uncle Sam is knocking on your door. If worse comes to worse, you will have to work with the IRS, set up a payment plan and then hope for a recovery in crypto markets.
And if you're going to buy in anticipation of a recovery, don't hold your breath for it to happen right after Tax Day.
Spring flower image via Shutterstock.
The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.